The Efficacy of Dynamic Stretching Exercise Versus Strengthening Exercise On Longitudinal Medial Arch in Flat Feet: Randomized Controlled Trial

  • Gondo A. A. Universitas Hasanuddin
  • Faadhilah N. Physiontastic Clinic
  • Nurjanati D. A. Physiontastic Clinic
  • Ramba Y. Politeknik Kesehatan Kemenkes Makassar
  • Abdullah M. M. Rumah Sakit Universitas Hasanuddin Makassar
Keywords: dynamic stretching exercise, strengthening exercise, longitudinal medial arch

Abstract

Introduction – Flat feet need to be treated with the proper exercises. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of dynamic stretching exercise with strengthening exercise in participants with flat feet. Methods – Participants included 73 subjects (12-14 years of age) with variety of flat feet degree who were recruited from a footprint with Arch Index (AI) and then randomly assigned to a dynamic stretching or strengthening treatment group. There were 35 participants in dynamic stretching group and 38 participants in strengthening group. The dynamic stretching treatment consisted of standing hamstring calf stretch, half kneeling with adductor stretch, and iliotibial band stretch. The strengthening treatment consisted of short foot, heel raise, and squat exercise. The main outcome measures were assessed with Independent T test for dependent variables. Results – There is statistically a significant difference between pre and post measurement readings with time (p = 0.00) and between groups (p < 0.05) with respect to longitudinal medial arch after 15 times exercise programs. Analysis showed more favor to dynamic stretching group (mean change, 0.031; 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.025, 0.036) rather than strengthening group (mean change, 0.021; 95% CI: 0.012, 0.029). Conclusion – Our results showed that dynamic stretching exercise programs was more effective in improving fallen longitudinal medial arch than strengthening exercise programs. These findings suggest that dynamic stretching exercise is a valid option for treatment of flat feet.

References

Behm, D.G., Chaouachi A. 2010. A Review of The Acute Effects of Static and Dynamic Stretching
on Performance. European Journal Appl Physiol,111(11):2633-51.
Evans, A., & Rome, K. 2011. Cochrane Review of The Evidence for Non Surgical Interventions for
flexible Pediatric Flat Feet. European Journal of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine.
Hermens, J Hermie. 2016. Musculosceletal Rehabilitation Clinic. Journal of Back and
Musculoskeletal Rehabilitation.Volume 31:6 Issues.
Kisner, C., Colby, LA. 2007. Theraputic Exercise. 5th ed. Philadelphia: F.A. Davis Company.
Lardner, R., Frank, C. C., and Page, P. 2010. Assessment and Treatment of Muscle Imbalance:
The Janda Approach. Phillipina: Human Kinetics.
Mosca, V. 2010. Flexible Flat Foot in Children and Adolescents. Journal of Child Orthopedic.
2010:107-121.
Perrier, Erica T., Pavol, Michael J., Hoffman, Mark A. 2011. The Acute Effects of A Warm-Up
Including Static or Dynamic Stretching on Countermovement Jump Height, Reaction Time and
Flexibility. The journal of Strength and Conditioning Research Volume 23. 1925-1931.
Pranati, K.Y., and Karthik, G. 2017. Assessment of Plantar Arch Index and Prevalence of Flat Feet
among South Indian Adolescent Population. Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research.
Sahabuddin, H. 2016. The Correlation between Flat Foot with Dynamic Balance. Makassar: Medical
Faculty, Hasanuddin University.
Santoso, D. 2011. The Proper Treatment for Your Flat Feet. Journal of Sport Injuries and
Rehabilitation.
Published
2019-09-20
Section
Articles